top of page

RS Reviews: Gordon the Big Engine - Some Rise and Fall, Others Fall and Rise (Bram)

9 minutes ago
13 min read


Some Rise and Fall, Others Fall and Rise.

Gordon the Big Engine

Reviewed by Bram

 

Introduction

While not necessarily my favorite Railway Series books, it is one that I believe to be well written.

I like its over arching storyline of Gordon causing trouble, being punished for the trouble, redeeming himself, and being restored to his former glory.

 

In addition, “Off the Rails,” and “Down the Mine” are two of the first Thomas stories I remember seeing via Thomas & Friends. (Though, due to the US retitles, I originally knew “Off the Rails” as “Gordon Takes a Dip;” or, as I used to call it as a small child- “Gordon Falls into a Ditch.” I think either my siblings or parents may have referred to it as this first.)

 

Because of seeing the TVS adaptations first, I will be mentioning them a lot- mostly how things didn’t make sense until I read the books. Especially since this story was adapted over the course of four seasons! I believe this contributes to how I feel this book is well-written; because it wasn’t until reading the original book at the age of 9 that I appreciated the overall story.

 

In this review, I will be going back and forth between recapping portions of the book and expressing (no pun intended!) my thoughts on those portions. Italics will indicate I am summarizing part of the book. Non-italics means I am expressing my opinions.

 

Off the Rails

Gordon is resting, when Henry passes by calling out “Hello, Fatface!”

 

This may be the best insult from the books ever! Due to the US changing it to “lazybones,” it wasn’t until I read the book I knew the real insult! Still amuses me how bold Henry was throwing this insult at him!

 

Gordon is furious that Henry would say such a thing to him- h i i i i m who’s never had an accident! Percy “innocently” asks “Aren’t jammed whistles and burst safety valves accidents?” Gordon insists they are not; they could happen to any engine. But coming off the rails like Henry did with The Flying Kipper did- Gordon suggests that’s wrong and indecent!

 

Because I saw the episodes rather out of order, it wasn’t until I got the Complete Railway Series, and read all the stories in order, that I understood what all the accidents and incidents were that they were referring to.

 

Also, when I read Gordon asking “Is it right? Is it decent?” I still read it in Ringo Starr’s voice, and think of the music cues.

 

Gordon later gets his own back at Henry (for the moment) as the latter gets ready to take the Express- warning him to not come off the rails! Henry goes off in a huff….

which the illustration doesn’t show very well…

and Gordon yawns and goes to sleep.

which the illustration does show very well!

 

Gordon’s sleep is soon interrupted when he is told he has to pull a special goods train. However, due to it being a goods train, he is stubborn, but is nonetheless pushed onto the turntable by Edward, and his fire burns well enough to make steam. Even now, Gordon is still determined to avoid pulling the train, and attempts to jam the turntable by moving slightly- throwing off the balance.

 

I must say, it wasn’t- again- until reading the books that I understood that he could jam the table without getting off it- unlike what my family members thought. (At least they had an idea- I had no idea how he could jam a table!)

 

However, Gordon rolls off the turntable and into a ditch!

 

Yet again, the book helped me understand that he truly comes off the rails! (Unlike the TV adaptation, where it appears he does not!)

Oh, the things Henry would have said if he had been there…!!

 

The Fat Controller is telephoned to be asked what to do. He says to tell Edward to take the special, and Gordon should just be left where he is.

 

Something that confuses me- one of the maps of Sodor indicates this accident occurred at Vicarstown. However, I believe that by this point Tidmouth was the main headquarters. However, the illustration shows Gordon being able to see from the window of The Fat Controller’s Office. However, like most of the nitpicks I will point out from this book, this is the fault of the illustrations- not the writing. Maybe it's just for poetic purposes.

 

Gordon is croaked at by a family of cross toads, sung at by some little boys, and blows away three tadpoles and an inquisitive newt in annoyance.

 

I would have loved to see some of those animals in the TVS adaptation. I bet they would have appeared in this modern CGI age, given all the other animal gags!

 

At last, that evening, Gordon is taken out of the ditch with help from James and Henry, and crawls home a sadder and wiser engine!

 

 

Sadder, wiser, and dirtier I dare add! (Also, of course, the TVS adaptation muffed Henry’s involvement. Always bothered me as a child. Still does as an adult!)

 

Leaves

Picking up where we left off (presumably the next day) Gordon is being washed by two men.

 

I love the banter between Gordon, Alf, and Bert. I also love how they are given names.

 

To quote the next part exactly:

The hosing and scrubbing stopped.

Gordon opened one eye, but shut it quickly.

 

I used to think that Alf and Bert were “trolling” Gordon, and that he shut his eye quickly because they started washing him again as soon as he opened his eye.

Now I realize he shut it because he saw The Fat Controller arrived- which I believe is also why the hosing and scrubbing stopped in the first place!

 

The Fat Controller tells Gordon that he will not pull coaches again until he has proven to be a really useful engine. Therefore, he can only take goods trains.

 

Last story we saw Gordon causing trouble- now we see his punishment. Because of how the television series adapted the stories (This particular one not being adapted until two seasons after “Off the Rails” and “Down the Mine” were!) we don’t get the full power of Gordon’s punishment in the TV series.

 

Gordon is very stern with his trucks while James watches him shunt them. Gordon at last explains it’s because they tried to push him down the hill. He warns James that the hill is slippery. James brushes him off.

 

I feel like this gives a good transition from Gordon to James. I imagine that, on top of James’s underlying vanity, he also brushes of Gordon because Gordon has been demoted to goods work. Furthermore, James is about to do one of Gordon’s usual jobs; pull the Express!

 

Trees were planted on Gordon’s hill to protect trains form strong winds. However, the leaves have fallen off because it’s Autumn now. They’d usually be blown away, but rain has made them wet and heavy.

 

I used to not understand that “leafy avenue” meant the leaves were still on the trees; so I was confused while it was mentioned the the leaves were falling now.

 

James at first is confident that he will make it up the hill. However he rapidly loses that confidence! They try adding sand to the rails, but that only turns the leaves to mud!

 

Oh dear. I guess sanding isn’t fool proof.

On another note, I think this may be the first time use of sanding is mentioned in the books!

 

Slowly James, stops. Then he starts going backwards down the hill! The Driver carefully and skillfully stops the train. The Driver remarks that he’s never known that sort of thing to happen before. The Fireman says he has; in Bincombe Tunnel in the Southern Region.

 

And here The Reverend W. Awdry takes the opportunity to credit his inspiration. I love that.

 

They then- after warning the signalman- back the train safely down the hill. Gordon, having followed with a goods train, saw what had happened. After a short teasing, he helps James by pushing from behind- once James has recovered steam.

 

There’s just something I love of how that goes. Gordon takes the opportunity to bring up James’s overconfidence, but soon lets it go and- as the text states- kindly agrees to helps him.

 

Together they make their way up the hill.

To quote the text directly:

The greasy wheels sometimes made Gordon’s wheels slip, but he never gave up…,

There’s just something I love about that- it shows Gordon’s determination.

 

Presently the make it to the top. James thanks him, and they whistle their goodbyes as James continues on. Gordon watches the coaches until they are out of sight, and then returns to his waiting trucks.

 

I love that ending. I’d like to take a moment to observe that last sentence, and repeat it word for word.

 

Gordon watched the coaches wistfully until they were out of sight; then slowly he trundled back to his waiting trucks.

 

It doesn’t say he watched James; it says he watched the coaches. Furthermore, it says he watches them wistfully. My analysis is that he longs to have his coach privileges back. Then it says he slowly returns to his trucks. Which shows that despite his longings, he is obediently returning to his goods train. 
Altogether, this sentence says that while Gordon has started to prove himself useful again, his punishment is not over yet.

Down the Mine

 

One day, Thomas is at the junction when Gordon arrives with some trucks.

 

Further proof that he is still under his punishment.

On another note, it kinda bugs me that Thomas and Gordon seem to each be at the wrong platforms! If they swapped it would be right!

 

Thomas takes this opportunity to reference Gordon’s accident; saying he smells a funny smell- finally revealing the alleged smell to be ditchwater.

 

Because this was adapted right after “Off the Rails,” you lose the full affect. With “Leaves” in between, you realize some time has passed after the ditch accident; nevertheless Gordon really is not living it down!

 

Thomas quickly puffs away- but Annie and Clarabel are shocked by Thomas’s rudeness. They still have a great respect for Gordon.

 

That just fascinates me, how they respect him.

On another note- another illustration annoyance; Thomas appears to be going backwards in both the illustrations; I’ve never quite understood why!

 

Thomas leaves Annie and Clarabel at a station to go to a mine.

 

Ah, we are approaching to one of the most famous of Thomas’s accidents. The mine- which outside source material reveals had once been a lead mine, but now is used for uranium.

 

Direct quote time:

Long ago, miners, digging for lead, had made tunnels under the ground.

 

For some reason I can only picture short old men with long beards digging for pick axes. Despite the old men in my head not being the dwarfs from Snow White, I think that’s where the picture comes from! Thanks, Disney.

 

The roofs of the tunnels can support trucks, but not engines. The famous notice warns “DANGER, ENGINES MUST NOT PASS THIS BOARD.” Thomas however- even with warning from others too!- thinks the board is silly, and has often tried to pass it unsuccessfully. This particular morning however, he has a plan! At the mine, The Fireman gets out of the cab to turn the points, and the driver leans out to get a better view.

 

It may be because of the danger theme from the adaptation, but the following part feels a bit intense to me!

 

Thomas seizes the opportunity, and bumps the trucks fiercely! Now with no one in his cab, he is free to pass the board. His Driver gets up to alert the Fireman, who gets back in and applies Thomas’s brakes- much to his annoyance. But before they can return, the ground quivers. The fireman jumps to safety just as Thomas falls down a mine!

 

I think it may be the combination of the danger theme, as well as how many more details there are compared to the adaptation, that makes this feel so intense while reading it.

 

Thomas at once realizes how silly he was. The Fat Controller (who somehow happens to be at the mine!) adds that Thomas was naughty as well. Thomas is a little dismayed when The Fat Controller concludes the best way to get Thomas out is for Gordon to pull him out!

 

Thomas knows the timing is bad- having to be helped by Gordon just after hours Thomas had been cheeky to him!

 

Once again, Gordon has a laugh, then compassionately helps- though he is nearly purple before he finally pulls Thomas out and safely pass the board!

 

Thomas apologies for being cheeky. Gordon accepts, saying that Thomas made him laugh- something he could use, being in disgrace. Thomas mentions that he’s in disgrace too. Upon realizing he’s right; that they are both in disgrace, Gordon offers to form an alliance. Thomas agrees, and together the Allies puff home.

 

 

This is something I am sad that we don’t see any more. Even in the “dark” era of the series – both model and CGI – we see Gordon and Thomas getting along despite their differences. While the series has improved in many ways, this is one place I feel it went the wrong way. I’d like to see more of a friendship between Thomas and Gordon again.

 

Paint Pots and Queens

 

The engines learn that the Queen is coming to the Island of Sodor! They speculate who will take the Royal Train. Edward and Gordon both admit they’re not likely- Edward says he’s too old, Gordon mentions that he’s still in disgrace. James and Henry however are confident. Henry thinks he has the upper wheel because James “can’t climb hills.”

 

And yet again, because of the way the stories were adapted for television, it wasn’t until I read the books that I understood why Henry made his (really burning!) remark about James and hills. Another thing I sort of miss in the current TV series; Henry could get cocky too! In fact, at this point, I think Henry is actually more stuck-up than Gordon is!

 

Henry puffs about proudly, feeling certain that he’ll pull the Royal Train. However, one rainy day, his smoke causes a painter on a ladder to lose his balance, and the painter lands on the tarpaulin used to shelter Henry’s Driver and Fireman from the rain. As for his paint bucket, it pours all over Henry! The painter is furious with Henry for ruining his paint job with his smoke, and then making him have to get more!

 

One of many examples where people on Sodor seem to not have their priorities quite straight! Instead of “You almost killed me!” it’s “you ruined my paint!”

I never noticed, until one of my siblings observed a similar example in “Thomas comes to Breakfast;” instead of the Stationmaster’s wife saying “you’ve smashed our house!” she says “you’ve ruined our breakfast!”

After that, I’ve noticed several other examples. However, I am not reviewing those books (at least for now), so I will not go into any more examples. I must say, I do love how we get to see the painter’s irritation, and how the text then says

He stumped crossly away.

I also love how it then says

The Fat Controller pushed his way through the crowd.

 

The Fat Controller says Henry looks like an iced cake; which will not do for the Royal Train! He will have to make other arrangements.

 

This is another insult that amuses me. However, I do feel a little bad for Henry; The Fat Controller’s statement implies that he truly was going to be the Royal Train, but now he’s lost it. Though, I have a feeling The Fat Controller may have been looking for any excuse to not choose Henry.

 

The Fat Controller goes to the Yard, where Gordon and Thomas see him. They both say “Please Sir…” The Fat Controller, smiling, asks them to speak one at a time.

 

I’ve always wanted to see that part be done with an individual voice cast!

 

The Fat Controller lets Gordon speak first. Gordon asks if Thomas can have his Branch Line again.

 

This may be my one big issue with this book that would be the fault of the writing. We never have heard any mention of Thomas losing his Branch line, but suddenly he apparently lost it (though it seems safe to assume he lost it as punishment for his Mine accident). It would have been nice if there had been some point where The Fat Controller told Thomas he lost his Branch line. If he had said it just before Thomas apologized to Gordon at the Mine, it would have given Thomas further reason to be in disgrace.

 

Another place I think it could’ve worked is at the beginning of this story, “Paint Pots and Queens.” It sounds like it would be abrupt, but the technique seemed to work several years later for the beginning of “Edward’s Exploit.”

 

But moving on…

 

The Fat Controller then lets Thomas speak. Thomas asks if Gordon can pull coaches again.

 

In the first story Gordon commits his wrongdoing. The second story begins with him receiving his punishment for the wrongdoing. And now, in the fourth and final story you see the request for his punishment to be lifted at long last.

 

One last time, you get the depth of this request far more in the book than in the TVs adaptations.

 

That aside, I love how the alliance between the two engines is continuing, and how each engine requests the other’s punishment is lifted.

 

The Fat Controller decides both engines have been good and deserve a treat. When the Queen comes, Thomas will arrange the coaches, Edward will clear the line, and Gordon will pull the Royal Train!

 

Talk about a great reward and honor for Gordon! Doesn’t seem like much of a treat for Thomas to me, but he’s got more coming later. As for Edward, I love how, despite being old, he still gets to play a special part in the visit!

 

At last, the great day arrives. Percy, Toby, Henry and James bring people to the town, while Thomas sorts their coaches. At last, Edward arrives, followed by Gordon with the Queen’s Train.

 

He is spotless, his brass is shining, and he is carrying the Royal Arms.

 

Again, talk about being honored! We saw Gordon’s fall, and now we see him being raised back up to his former position and beyond!

 

All the engines- especially Toby and Percy- are excited and delighted to see the Queen, who speaks to all of them in turn. The next day, when she leaves she specially talks to Thomas, Edward and Gordon.

 

Like I said, Thomas’s treat would be coming!

 

And to conclude by directly quoting the rest of the sentence:

…and no engines ever felt prouder than Thomas, and Edward, and Gordon the Big Engine.

 

I've always loved the last words of the book are the book’s title.

 

In Conclusion

 

Gordon the Big Engine is a story of the titular character’s fall, punishment, and complete redemption. (I can’t help but feel connections between it and elements of my faith! I won’t go into a theological thing; I just I wanted to admit feeling a connection. It’s actually not surprising to me, given the author was a Reverend!) The television series did not, in my opinion, do complete justice to the overall story. And because I read the book after the TV episodes, I appreciate the overall story all the more.

 

That is why, to me, Gordon the Big Engine stands out to me as a well written book.

 

Comments


bottom of page