top of page

RS Book Reviews: Main Line Engines (Joe Gibbons)

2 hours ago
3 min read

Main Line Engines

Reviewed by Joe Gibbons


The four stories in these books - but especially those made for Series 2 in 1986 - are all immaculately written by the Reverend Awdry; 'The Diseasal' is a brilliant quirky, funny start to the volume which introduces us to the dynamic trio of Bill, Ben and BoCo (accompanied, of course, by Edward), and seems appropriate in its approach to bringing the North-Western Railway back as the predominant feature of the books after two installments spent away on the Skarloey and Culdee Fell Railways (albeit with supporting appearances from Duck and Donald) by bringing in three new and wonderful characters to set the scene for this volume, due to its well-timed humour, typically Awdry-esque characters with charming dialogue and characterisation - no wonder it's one of Andrew Brenner's favourite stories; also worth noting that I suspect Britt Allcroft and David Mitton went back to this story when making 'One Good Turn' and 'Double Teething Troubles' in the '90s.


'Buzz, Buzz' is good in that we see more of BoCo interacting with the other engines and learn more about his character; Duck also shows character development here, overcoming his past prejudices against certain OTHER Diesels (albeit with good reason in the case of Book 13) - and as ever, James is boastful, proud and stubborn: all the necessary ingredients that lead him to trouble later in the story; not among my top stories in either books or TV Series, but it's always a good laugh to see this particular MAIN LINE ENGINE getting into mayhem.


We then move on to 'Wrong Road', in which we return to Edward's Branch Line and the dynamic is mixed-up again; only this time, Gordon - after hurling some harsh comments about branch lines to Edward - ends up falling victim to Bill and Ben in a richly entertaining scene that I'm sure long-term readers and Gordon-fans alike had waited a long time to see when first published in '66. Couple of side notes here - I've always been a mega-fan of Gunvor & Peter Edwards' artwork, but particularly in this volume and particularly in this story: the opening image of Thomas crossing the River at Elsbridge is lovely, and it's nice to see him get some attention (albeit in a cameo) for the first and only time during a run of seven books (from 'Mountain Engines' to 'Duke the "Lost" Engine') without him featuring as a principal character. The other image that stands out in my mind is the fifth one of the story, where we see Gordon idling at Brendam - with the twin tank engines creeping into the background looking their cheekiest, and setting up the madness that ensues!


Finally; I don't there's much I can say about 'Edward's Exploit' that others haven't said already; it's exciting, thrilling and the absolute perfect conclusion to an already rich set of stories - the art is stunning, and Edward (the character who started it all so long ago) is back in the limelight with what is arguably the best story ever written about the character; I always wince much like poor Edward when I see how pained he looks in the third illustration - but the Blue Engine prevails, and this is a strong message to carry over to children; one that carries over to adulthood as well: don't give up, never let your peers put you down and give it all you've got.


Comments


bottom of page